Gov. Gavin Newsom declared a state of emergency in Orange County on Saturday afternoon as the temperature inside a malfunctioning chemical storage tank in Garden Grove rose to dangerous levels while crews attempted to head off a disastrous explosion, and tens of thousands of residents remained under evacuation orders.
Crews who “put themselves in harm’s way” overnight realized that the interior temperature of the tank, which authorities previously believed had been dropping, was not actually cooling, officials said.
That left fire officials on Saturday still racing to find an “out of the box” solution to the compromised tank at GKN Aerospace in Garden Grove, amid dire predictions that it could either explode — potentially unleashing a fireball and chemical plume — or crack as 7,000 gallons of chemicals pour out.
See Also: Map shows Garden Grove hazmat incident and evacuation around aerospace plant
Officials did express hope of another option that would allow their current strategy of dousing the tank with water to slow a potential chemical reaction that would ignite an explosion.
The emergency proclamation by Newsom unlocks additional resources for local officials, and directs state emergency operations officials to focus on supporting local authorities in grappling with the ongoing emergency.
“The safety of Orange County residents is the top priority,” Newsom said in a statement. “We are mobilizing every state resource available to support local responders and make sure the community has what they need to stay safe.”
Meanwhile, officials said around 50,000 people in portions of six cities — Garden Grove, Stanton, Westminster, Cypress, Buena Park and Anaheim — along with unincorporated county land were under evacuation orders by mid-Saturday.
The evacuation area was crafted to accommodate even the most catastrophic outcome, such as an explosion, officials said. A map displayed by fire officials that outlined an area near the plant that would be most severely damaged in the event of an explosion appeared to include industrial and business space to the west, north and south, and an unspecified number of residential homes to the west.
Avoiding a dire scenario
Orange County Fire Authority crews first responded to GKN Aerospace on Thursday afternoon, following reports that an overheated tank had begun venting vapors. Firefighters sprayed the tank down with water to cool the chemical in the tank: methyl methacrylate, a toxic and highly flammable liquid chemical.
On Friday, worsening conditions forced authorities to set up a roughly 1-mile buffer around the tank.
Fire officials on Friday offered a bleak assessment: The tank would fail and spill 7,000 gallons of “very bad chemicals” into a parking lot, which they described as the preferable option. Or the tank would go into “thermal runaway” and blow up, a more dire scenario.
In order to avoid the worst outcome, crews were focused on keeping the temperature in the tank down. They described approximately 100 degrees as the point at which things could go out of control.
Fire crews in harm’s way
Looking at readings from drones on the outside of the tank, crews late Friday believed they had gotten the temperature down to 61 degrees, and were hoping to get it down to 50 degrees, the point at which they believed it was possible to neutralize the threat.
Based on those readings, fire crews aided by a chemist team went from defense to offense on Friday night and went “in harm’s way” into the facility to try to neutralize the tank, Incident Commander Craig Covey said in a video update.
See Also: What is methyl methacrylate, the substance at the center of a Garden Grove hazmat emergency?
But when the firefighters and chemists saw the actual tank, they learned the actual temperature was higher than they expected.
“Unfortunately, the temperature was 90 degrees,” Covey said. “Yesterday morning, it was 77 degrees when we backed out. It is averaging about a degree an hour increasing.”
A new outcome?
An explosion or a rupture and a spill remain two possible outcomes, Covey said.
But authorities are beginning to consider a third outcome: that a chemical reaction inside the tank is turning the liquid into a solid, and that there may be enough capacity in the “void space” above the liquid chemicals to handle the resulting pressure. Covey said the “heavy deluge of water and cooling it” is “allowing it to cool at a slower rate and reducing its overpressure.” He compared it to “an ice cube that freezes from the outside in.”
“We are bringing people in from all over the country, talking to people from all over the place, trying to come up with additional options,” Covey said. “Letting this thing just fail and blow up is unacceptable to us.”
As they consider other options, fire crews have continued to spray the tank down with water. While some on social media have questioned the safety of the runoff going into the streets and drains, fire officials mid-Saturday said there were no current leaks from the tank, and the runoff was just water without any chemicals in it.
Dr. Elaine Bernal, a lecturer in the Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry at Cal State Long Beach, said the chemical reaction going on inside the tank is causing the chemical to harden and solidify, creating heat in the process. The tank holds 34,000 gallons of the chemical in liquid form, Bernal said, but as it solidifies and shrinks, it takes up less volume.
“The idea is to slow down the chemical reaction inside the tank. Basically, controlling for the heat — a steady solidification where it doesn’t react and solidify so fast,” Bernal said.
If fire officials are correct about the water deluge slowing the process and there is enough room in the tank to contain the chemical in its resulting solid state, Bernal said that would provide enough time for officials to consider their next steps once either is stabilized.
“The best thing we can do is really focus on the current monitoring on what is going on in the tank,” she added.
Trying to stabilize the system
Finding a way to reliably reduce the temperature within the tank or release the chemicals in a controlled way has proven elusive.
The valves that are usually used to control the tank are gummed up. The tank itself is made of thick steel, and even attempting to drill into it could create heat and spark the highly volatile chemicals, Orange County Fire Authority Capt. Steve Concialdi said.
Bernal agreed that attempting to drill into the tank could be dangerous, since it could spark a reaction that could cause the chemical to ignite.
“You don’t want to introduce any side chemical reactions, you don’t want to introduce anything invasive,” she said.
The crews who entered the plant on Friday night were planning to introduce a chemical stabilizer meant to harden up the liquid chemicals, Concialdi said. They were able to add that stabilizer to two nearby tanks, but weren’t able to put it into the unstable tank before having to leave the area due to the higher-than-expected temperature.
While authorities acknowledged the large size of the evacuation zone was disruptive to the community, they wanted to make sure that no one would be in danger in the event of an explosion.
“Our hearts go out to all of them, but it is for their safety,” Concialdi said of the residents impacted by the evacuation orders.
See Also: Panic and confusion described by some forced to evacuate due to Garden Grove chemical scare
In the event of an explosion, there would be metal from the tank and nearby tanks, debris from the plant and chemicals all pushed into the air.
Normally, the chemical gases would stay close to the ground, since they are heavier than air, Concialdi noted. But an explosion with a large fireball would send the liquid and the vapors into the atmosphere.
Exactly how far the gas would travel would depend on the wind, which is expected to pick up in the afternoon on Saturday.
In the event of the tank cracking and the chemicals rapidly leaking out — a less catastrophic option — fire crews have set up a system of sand barriers to prevent the chemicals from entering storm drains or river channels.
But while an explosion would result in a more dramatic spread of the chemicals, even a leak would introduce it out into the community.
“Either way there will be vapors that are in the air,” Bernal said. “The wind can still pick it up.”
See Also: How worried should you be about a Garden Grove chemical spill or explosion’s impact on your health?
While there have been no reports so far of active gas leaks or plumes, the air quality in the area is being monitored and officials have strongly urged residents to adhere to the evacuations given the potential danger. Officials from the South Coast Air Quality Management District and the U.S. EPA confirmed late Saturday that testing in the area confirmed air quality remained at normal levels.
Evacuation centers have been set up at Freedom Hall at 16801 Euclid St. in Fountain Valley, Savanna High School at 301 N. Gilbert St. in Anaheim, John F. Kennedy High School at 8281 Walker St. in La Palma and Oceanview High School at 17071 Gothard St. in Huntington Beach.
U.S. Rep. Derek Tran, whose district includes areas impacted by the evacuations, said during a news conference mid-Saturday that there was no current timeline for the evacuations.
“Perhaps the largest question they have is when they will be able to move back in,” said Tran, D-Cypress. “The answer is we don’t know. … Safety is paramount. I am urging all residents inside the impacted area to make sure they evacuate.”
Tran declined to comment on any potential contingency plans in the event of an explosion, referring reporters to fire authorities.
“What they have been telling us is that they are planning for every contingency possible,” Tran said. “I suspect with the fact the governor has now declared a state of emergency a lot more resources are going to be coming in from the state level to help with this.”
The Garden Grove Strawberry Festival Parade was canceled, though the actual Strawberry Festival itself remained open, according to the city. A planned vote center will not open, and an OC Food Bank was shut down.
A deep investigation
Cal/OSHA has confirmed that they will open an inspection report for the GKN Aerospace plant where the tank is located, though they have released no other details.
Tran said he has already reached out to the president of the company. The focus at the moment is getting the situation under control, Tran said, but he added he is also calling for a “deep investigation” about what happened.
“I shared with him that I’m not happy about what is happening right now, but I need the company to focus on making sure they help with the response, that they help with any of the engineering questions that are related to the manufacturing and installation and inspection of the tank.”
“I also let him know the displacement of all these residents, and the use of all of these resources locally, is very expensive,” Tran added. “So, I expect the company needs to step up and take ownership of this.”
The plant on Western Avenue has been in the city for more than three decades. Prior to the current crisis, it was primarily known as the worldwide leading manufacturer of cockpit windshields, jet canopies and aviation windows for civil and military aircraft.
See Also: Garden Grove plant with chemical emergency is leading maker of aviation windows, canopies
The chemical at the center of the crisis — methyl methacrylate — is a highly toxic substance that in the short term can impact a person’s respiratory system, cause skin irritation and eye irritation, officials said. But little is known about the long-term effects of the substance on humans, health officials said Friday. Encountered at high levels, officials said it could cause severe respiratory distress and hospitalizations.
Displaced residents
As the crisis continued Saturday, local cities worked to deal with displaced residents.
At midday, Stanton Mayor David Shawver urged everyone in that city to leave, suggesting they go to the emergency shelter in Huntington Beach. The city of Stanton covers a little more than 3 square miles and has fewer than 40,000 residents, according to the 2020 U.S. Census. A large portion of the city was already affected by mandatory evacuations.
About 2,000 homes in Anaheim were in the evacuation zone, according to city spokesman Mike Lyster, estimated to impact between 4,000 and 6,000 residents.
“We continue to watch and work our way through this,” he said.
About 200 people stayed at Savanna High School overnight, which Lyster believes could be largest among the centers. The center remained open overnight Saturday, but officials are looking to find another location, for the coming days, if the evacuation orders persist, as the school will need its gym back come Tuesday.
Viri Morales, 43, a behavioral interventionist at Brookhurst Elementary, evacuated her West Garden Grove home with her daughter, son, granddaughter and two cats Friday afternoon. Morales lives less than 1.5 miles north from GKN Aerospace.
“I knew that factory was there,” Morales said. “I was just not aware of the danger that it was for the community.”
Morales said there are “more questions than answers” about the crisis unfolding in her hometown: “Not knowing if we’re going to go back home. If it explodes, how big will the blast be? Will it blow up the windows or is our city going to burn? Who’s going to be affected? Why weren’t any precautions in place to prevent it from getting to the point where we have to evacuate 40,000 people?
“I’ve been looking at all the recordings from the Orange County Fire Authority. They say a lot of the same thing,” she said. “They don’t have concrete answers.”
Officials buy time against possible chemical tank explosion in Garden Grove
